Court Excoriates ‘Copyright Troll’ Attorney and Provides $100,000 in Sanctions

Court Excoriates ‘Copyright Troll’ Lawyer and Adds $100,000 in Sanctions


Richard LiebowitzOver the earlier a number of many years, photographers have submitted hundreds of lawsuits in opposition to firms that allegedly use their get the job done with no permission.

The vast majority of these cases, which include prominent targets this kind of as Yahoo.com, Verizon.com, MSN.com, MTV.com, Gawker.com, are handled by lawyer Richard Liebowitz.

We to start with spotted this rising craze in 2016 and, at the time, Liebowitz advised us that he was aiding independent photographers to shield their legal rights. All also usually, companies would choose their function devoid of spending.

“Copyright infringement is an ongoing issue. Organizations are making use of other people’s hard function and profiting off of it. It is crucial for photographers and the resourceful group to unite and stand up for their legal rights and shield their perform,” Liebowitz claimed.

Liebowitz&#8217 misconduct and sanctions

Considering the fact that then, a ton has happened. Though copyright infringement continues to be a trouble for photographers, Liebowitz has predominantly built a title for himself as a result of his controversial tactics. Courts have sanctioned the lawyer for different styles of misconduct, reaching a new milestone late past 7 days.

A scathing buy issued by US District Courtroom Decide Jesse M. Furman leaves minor to the creativity, starting up with some history facts on Liebowitz&#8217s young but troubled profession.

The lawyer handed the bar in 2015 and submitted his to start with copyright case a few months afterwards. Considering that 2017, he has filed numerous issues. What stands out just as significantly, nonetheless, is the variety of times courts have sanctioned him for misconduct.

&#8220In that similar interval, he has acquired a different doubtful distinction: He has become a single of the most frequently sanctioned lawyers, if not the most regularly sanctioned lawyer, in the District,&#8221 Choose Furman writes.

Judge Furman order sanctions against Richard Liebowitz

The Judge notes that the lawyer was frequently chastised and warned by courts, exactly where other judges described him as “a copyright troll,” “a obvious and present danger to the reasonable and productive administration of justice,” and an “example of the worst kind of lawyering.”

Some of these descriptions also look to use to the current lawsuit, which yet again spiraled out of regulate.

Usherson v. Bandshell

The scenario in concern was submitted on behalf of photographer Arthur Usherson and accused Bandshell Artist Management of applying just one of his images with out permission. As the circumstance progressed, even so, the legal professional&#8217s questionable methods took centre stage.

Liebowitz violated at the very least six courtroom orders and regularly lied to the Court, even less than oath. In addition, he falsely claimed that the picture&#8217s copyright was registered when the lawsuit was filed, which turned out not to be legitimate.

In a 54-web site order (pdf), Decide Furman goes around each of these problems and in the long run reaches the conclusion that, offered the legal professional&#8217s &#8220deplorable file,&#8221 techniques ought to be taken to suspend the attorney&#8217s capability to file new instances.

Sanctions and a Possible Ban

This conclusion is ultimately up to the Grievance Committee of the courtroom, which acquired a duplicate of the order. This could eventually lead to a ban on training in the Manhattan Federal Court, as Everyday News notes.

Even so, that doesn&#8217t suggest that there&#8217s no punishment. Decide Furman ordered Liebowitz and his legislation company to shell out sanctions totaling $103,517.49. On best of that, the legal professional ought to mail a copy of the belief to all of his recent shoppers.

This is not the initially time the legal professional has been sanctioned and no matter whether this buy will transform everything continues to be to be witnessed. That reported, presented his monitor document, upcoming cases will probably obtain themselves under a magnifying glass.

TorrentFreak arrived at out to Mr. Liebowitz for a comment on the get but we have nonetheless to get a response.

&#8212

Photograph credit score: Liebowitz picture by&#8221King of Hearts&#8221 (CC BY-SA 4.)

From: _, for the most up-to-date information on copyright battles, piracy and a lot more.

Written by David Minister

By David Minister

Sending
User Review
0 (0 votes)

Last Updated on

Be the first to comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.


*